Why Did the Thunder-Pacers NBA Finals Game 1 Have the Worst Ratings in Decades?

Content for everyone

The 2025 NBA Finals between the Oklahoma City Thunder and Indiana Pacers reportedly had historically low ratings for Game 1, which can be attributed to several factors:

1. Small Market Teams – Why It Matters

  • Historical Precedent: The NBA has always struggled with Finals ratings when small-market teams make it (e.g., Spurs vs. Pistons in 2005 had the lowest ratings before 2025; Spurs vs. Cavs in 2007 also suffered).

  • Media Bias: ESPN/TNT tend to prioritize big-market teams (Lakers, Knicks, Warriors) in coverage, leaving casual fans less familiar with OKC/Indy.

  • Bandwagon Effect: Fewer neutrals tune in because neither team has a massive national following.

Comparison:

  • 2024 Finals (Celtics vs. Mavericks) had much higher ratings because:

    • Boston is a legacy franchise.

    • Dallas has Luka Dončić (global superstar).


2. Superstar Problem – The NBA’s Marketing Crisis

  • Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (OKC) and Tyrese Haliburton (IND) are elite, but neither is a household name like LeBron, Curry, or Giannis.

  • Social Media Influence: Stars like Ja Morant (despite controversies) or Victor Wembanyama drive more buzz than SGA/Haliburton.

  • No “Villain” Team: Fans love to hate dynasties (Warriors, Heatles), but OKC/IND are seen as “likable underdogs,” which doesn’t fuel drama.

Case Study:

  • 2021 Bucks vs. Suns had mediocre ratings despite Giannis’ heroics because Phoenix and Milwaukee aren’t glamour markets.


3. Competition & Scheduling – What Else Was On?

  • Stanley Cup Finals: If NHL’s finals (featuring big markets like Toronto or NYC) overlapped, hockey could’ve stolen viewers.

  • MLB Season: A marquee Yankees-Dodgers series or a no-hitter could’ve diverted attention.

  • Streaming Wars: If Game 1 was behind a paywall (e.g., NBA League Pass or Max’s Bleacher Report), casual fans may not have tuned in.

Recent Trend:

  • The NFL dominates ratings, and even MLB’s Pitch Clock era has made baseball more engaging, pulling away sports fans.


4. Playoff Fatigue – Was the Road to the Finals Boring?

  • If the conference finals were sweeps or blowouts (e.g., Thunder/Wolves in 4 games), fans might’ve lost interest before the Finals.

  • Lack of Drama: No legacy rivalries (e.g., Lakers vs. Celtics), no revenge narratives (e.g., Durant vs. Warriors), no Cinderella stories.

Example:

  • 2023 Nuggets vs. Heat had decent but not great ratings because Miami’s Cinderella run was offset by Denver’s small-market status.


5. Broadcast & Streaming – The New TV Dilemma

  • Cable Decline: Traditional TV ratings are down across all sports—more fans watch highlights on YouTube/Instagram instead of full games.

  • Fragmented Viewing: If the NBA split broadcasts between ABC/ESPN/streaming, some fans may have missed it.

  • Gen Z Habits: Younger audiences prefer short-form content (TikTok highlights) over 3-hour games.

Data Point:

  • The 2024 NFL Draft had higher ratings than some NBA playoff games—shifting sports consumption trends.


6. Economic & Cultural Shifts

  • Cost of Living Crisis: Fans may cancel cable/streaming subscriptions to save money.

  • Gambling Influence: Less betting hype around OKC/IND compared to bigger markets.

  • International Appeal: Neither team has a massive global fanbase (unlike the Warriors with Curry’s Asia influence or Lakers’ worldwide brand).


Can the Series Recover?

  • If the games are all-time classics (multiple OTs, controversial calls, breakout performances), word-of-mouth could boost later games.

  • Social Media Moments: A viral dunk or Haliburton/SGA duel could spark interest.

  • Media Push: ESPN/NBA may overhype narratives (e.g., “Chet Holmgren’s redemption!”) to draw eyes.

But realistically, without a major market or superstar, this could go down as the lowest-rated Finals in modern history.


Final Thought: Is This a Long-Term NBA Problem?

The league is at a crossroads:
Pros: Young talent (Wemby, SGA, Haliburton) is exciting, but…
Cons: If small-market teams keep winning, will casual fans care?